Revised 9.21.10
1937 Louis Gerke and Otto Buesking approached Rev William Gustave Polack, who also had a cottage on
1938 The first service was held July 3, 1938 in the abandoned brick
1939 John and Vally Oehler donated several lots on the hill behind their grocery store on the south side of
GROUNDBREAKING APRIL 15, 1939
ONLY FIVE WEEKS LATER
1940 The Estey electro-pneumatic organ was dedicated in the first anniversary service on June 30. Pauline Buesking served as organist. People were encouraged bring their children and dress informally. Visitors were offered use of the picnic tables and grounds, dressing rooms and ready access to the beach.
1941 More ground was acquired and an outdoor public address system was installed to accommodate those who could not be seated indoors. Chairs were placed on a platform on the east of the building. Every Saturday evening at 6 PM sacred music was broadcast over the lake.
1942 In recognition of his literary achievements,
FOUNDING PASTOR GUSTOV POLACK
1943 Consideration was given to founding a Walther League Camp at the lake. Gas rationing kept some from often coming to the lake. A girl’s sextet was formed consisting of Lois Dreyer, Carol Ernsting, Bev Koeneman, Carolyn Meyer, Shirley Ann Preuss and Ruth Strasser. On July 4th the huge rugged outdoor cross and the painting of Christ preaching from the boat were dedicated. Two lots east of the chapel (61&62) were acquired for taxes of $14.72.

1944
1945 Services were only held during the summer months until once-a-month ‘off season’ services were inaugurated in the fall of 1945, including Sunday School and Bible Class. The first Children’s Christmas program was held. Both a summer program and a winter group elected offices. The Clear Lake Lutheran Chapel Association (the summer group) owned the building. Each year the winter group would request the right to use the facility and it was formally granted. On July 1st the gold lettering in the sanctuary, “The Lord is in His Holy Temple,” given by Mrs Bertha Cobb (later Zelt), was dedicated. Services at the chapel were broadcast over WGL in Ft Wayne.
1946 Pews were installed and summer Sunday School was begun using religious ‘sound’ films (one was in full color!)
1947 A vestry for the pastor was added to the west of the chancel “a small room similar to that on the east side.” The Ladies Aid Society was organized. A 100’ x 150’ donated plot across the street from the chapel was set aside as a cemetery (The 1947 minutes give credit to John Oehler who purchased the land from Arnold Koeneman to give to the association, but see note of 1954). An oil burning furnace was added.
1948 The stone altar, given in memory of Henry and Amelia Tonne was dedicated for use at outdoor services. The basement was divided into a kitchen and a Sunday School room. On July 4, 1948 the congregation celebrated its 10th anniversary with Dr O.P. Kretzmann, President of Valparaiso University preaching, and, in an afternoon service, honored Pastor Polack for ten years of service. The motto of the anniversary program: “The Church with the Message and the Welcome” An article for the tenth anniversary reported, “Throughout the summer months every pew is filled with children and adults for the 9:45 am Bible School and by 10:30 am when regular church service opens the chapel is filled and an overflow crowd is assembled on the lawn to join in the worship.” Average summer attendance for 13 services was 286.
1949 A heart warming series of sermons prepared by the shores of
1950 Founding Pastor, Dr Polack died of a brain tumor on June 5th and after a memorial service at Concordia Seminary in St Louis, a service was held at Clear Lake Chapel on June 7th where he was buried in the newly dedicated cemetery (only the second to be buried there, the first being one day old Craig Kuntz.) In a letter to the congregation Arnold Koeneman expressed regret that “Dr Polack did not realize his greatest dream for the Chapel, to see it grow into a permanent year around congregation with a full time pastor.” A marble cross monument and chimes were given in his memory.
The Rev Armin Oldsen, then professor at
PASTOR ARMIN OLDSEN
1951 A summer parsonage on the East shore was acquired by the association for the price of $13,900 and Armin and Evelyn moved in with their four sons. Armin Oldsen was selected as the speaker for the Lutheran Hour, a position he held for three years. His sermons were translated into 56 languages and broadcast throughout the world. Prof Henry Kumnick of
1952 Average summer Sunday attendance was 517. On Oct 28th a constitution was signed by members of the winter group – the nucleus of what was to become a year round congregation. Monthly potlucks where the church’s business was conducted were held from September to May – a practice that was continued until 1968. The congregation was using a Bohn organ. Ed Bohn of the Bohn organ company was a regular worshipper. Rolene Kaufman and Noreen Hess played the organ and piano for winter services.
1953 Average summer attendance had reached 500 and record attendance one Sunday was just short of one thousand. Often on Sundays throughout the 50’s and 60’s a different guest choir from
OVERFLOW SEATING
1954 Armin Oldsen called as pastor of St Paul Lutheran in
1955
1956 Rev Kumnick retired and moved to
1957 Pastor Oldsen took a call to be director of Religious Education at
1958 The mortgage on the parsonage was paid off and average summer attendance had risen to 605.
1959 The congregation considered building an outdoor pavilion north of the building in front of the outdoor altar to be built in sections as needed with each section to seat 300 people. Another suggestion was to build the pavilion west of the cemetery. New matching pulpit and lectern placed in sanctuary
1960 The plans for an outdoor pavilion were dropped in favor of an expansion of the church facility. A children’s choir was formed and sang for services for two years.
1961
1962 25th Anniversary Season. A 10 foot addition to the north end of the chapel provided a new chancel, sacristy and lounge room; a redecorated sanctuary with indirect lighting and new carpeting; an indoor stairway to the basement on the northeast corner and added and enlarged rest rooms. The cost was $6,500. Louis Gehrke was chairman of the remodeling committee. Leroy Gehrke donated the electrical work and Otto W Bergman donated the plumbing. Stained glass panels replaced the painting of Christ in the boat and formed the rear wall of the chancel and a decorative wood panel and two wood symbols IHS (Jesus) and XP (Christ) made by Harold Panning, shop teacher of
1963 Stained glass windows on the street side of the chapel were given in memory of Dr G. W. Polack by his children and dedicated the last Sunday in August. The marble memorial cross in the cemetery was vandalized and repaired. An organ fund was begun. The front entrance was updated with new doors and an overhanging canopy. The congregation voted to give a tithe of its income to the Lutheran Church- Missouri Synod (opposed by some because earlier the then Synod of Missouri,
1964 A recommendation for an outside pavilion for the east side of the church to “eliminate the need to carry so many chairs and so that worshipers might be able to see the minister” was discussed but abandoned in 1966. The practice of making copies of ‘Portals of Prayer’ available was begun.
1965 Pastor Oldsen accepted a call to be pastor of Trinity,
1966 Winter attendance averaged over 100 for the first time. The possibility of bringing together the summer and winter groups was raised.
1967 New speaker system installed. Plans for a circular pavilion to the northwest of the chapel “in which all worshippers will be seated together surrounded by the beauty of God’s nature.” were considered and later abandoned.
1968 On August 31st, 1968 the Clear lake Lutheran Chapel Association transferred ownership of all its property and grounds including the cemetery and parsonage to the
1969 On New Years day in a special service, a plaque was hung commemorating the transfer of all property of the Association to the congregation. On June 1st a constitution with bylaws was adopted and the congregation incorporated as a self supporting congregation of the Lutheran Church- Missouri Synod. The well system was replaced.

1970 A building committee presented three plans for remodeling. A “Cross Design” was chosen. A stairway to the basement at the street end of the church was also proposed as well as a roof over the door exiting to the east and a wood and glass screen at the rear of the nave.
1971 Major remodeling of the entrance, expansion of the nave with transepts to the east and west with beautiful stained glass windows by City Glass of Ft Wayne, an expanded chancel area to the north to form a cross shaped building, a stairway to the basement was added on the road side of the building, a new kitchen under the east wing, and a remodeled “fellowship hall” were completed at a cost of $75,000. Herman Muesing was the chairman of the building committee, the architect was John Dickerson and the General Contractor was the Behrmann Construction Company. The area under the west wing and chancel area was open and provided room for outdoor seating and picnic tables. A new natural gas furnace was installed and 21 new pews were purchased. The entire chapel was covered with aluminum siding and a high, white aluminum spire was placed on the old belfry tower. Wiring for the hard of hearing was also installed. Herb and Blanche Tonne underwrote the entire cost of a new west entrance. A rededication service was held Sept 5, 1971 with the chancel choir of the St Paul Lutheran,
NEW ENTRANCE
1972 Four stained glass windows in the main section of the church, with a four season theme designed by Rev Oldsen, were given as a memorial for Mrs Minnie Koeneman, a charter member.
1973 The grassy parking area west of the church was paved.
1974 On August 11 the congregation observed Rev Oldsen’s 25th year as pastor. Rev Oswald Hoffman of the Lutheran Hour was the preacher. New communion ware and baptismal font were purchased.
1975

THE REV ARMIN OLDSEN
1976 The construction loan from 1971 was paid off and a mortgage burning ceremony was held. The church grounds were decorated for the bicentennial of the
1977 A retirement dinner for Rev Oldsen was sold out at the Potawatomi Inn with over 500 guests. The parsonage was sold to Rev Oldsen and he was made Pastor Emeritus in recognition of his long service. On October 23rd, Rev Loren J. Shiley was installed. Church office equipment was purchased and church bulletins were begun
1978 The proceeds from the sale of the parsonage ($32,500) and $7,586 from the general fund were invested into Pastor Shiley’s new residence by means of a second mortgage of $40,366. The parking lot was paved.
1979 The fortieth anniversary of the church was celebrated.
1980 After persisting for three years, Pastor Shiley convinced the congregation to replace the 15 year old electric organ with a
1981 Various plans were drawn up and discussed for new entrances and a bell tower. The vestibule was repaired and the tower replaced at a cost of $5,262. In June the congregation celebrated Pastor Shiley’s 30th anniversary in the ministry. However a letter criticizing Pastor Shiley was circulated – issues included the repayment schedule on his house loan and his influence on the organ purchase, and a controversy erupted with strong feelings expressed on both sides.
1982 After a period of dissension and turmoil that split the congregation, the Board of Directors asked Rev Shiley to resign effective May 30, 1982. Rev Shiley declined to do so. A ballot was distributed to all members and 115 voted to ask Rev Shiley to leave and 84 wanted him to stay with 33 abstaining.
1983 On Jan 7th the locks on the church were changed and Pastor Shiley was denied entrance. CLLC sold 200 chairs to Bob Moore. When the LCMS Commission of Adjudication issued a ruling in favor of Pastor Shiley, he notified the congregation of his intention to return to the pulpit on July 17th. However, this offer was met with the cancellation of services on that day. On July 28th, with Dr E.H. Zimmerman, president of the Indiana District of the LCMS, present as an observer, the congregation, by a vote of 104 to 0 (the Shiley supporters boycotted the meeting), voted to officially remove Rev Shiley. Some of the members had left with Pastor Shiley in January and met in
1984 Rev Zilz continued to serve until Rev Herman Reese was installed as the new pastor in December. Twenty five robes were purchased for the choir (Keith Gnagy, director).

1985
1986 The free standing bell tower was finally erected. The bell tower was designed and constructed by Bill Scheumann, a member of the congregation. The 900 pound bell, donated by Barbara Spears in memory of her husband, John, was cast in 1895 and electrified by I.T. Verdin Co.
1987
1988 The church struggled financially throughout the 80’s. Service time was changed from 10 am and set for 9 am Worship and 10 am Sunday School. The 50th anniversary celebration was begun with a special service on May 22 with Melvin Zilz preaching and continued on July 24th with Armin Oldsen preaching. An anniversary thankoffering was begun with the goal of enclosing the undercroft for a Sunday school room.
1989
1990 In January Rev Herman Reese was called to St Luke,
1991 The funds from the sale of the parsonage were placed in a 15 year 9% Lutheran Church Extension Fund CD for future use (It was due to mature at $181,797 in Feb, 2006 but because a $10,000 withdrawal was made in 1998 to help pay for a new roof the final amount was @161,000).
1992

VACATION BIBLE SCHOOL WORKERS
1993 A light for the parking lot was installed in memory of Betty Stegelmann who many years earlier had almost been denied entry to the
1994 The patio garden overlooking the outdoor worship space was landscaped in memory of Rudolf and Marie Stegelmann.
1995 A new well was dug. Kenneth Redmann served as a vicar under the supervision of Rev Meseke. 45 people registered for a Crossways Bible Study. Stained glass windows donated earlier by the Fremont Bank were installed in the chancel, replacing the colored windows and reredos (wooden panel).
PASTOR GIL MESEKE LEADS OUTDOOR WORSHIP
1996 Pastor Kenneth Redmann ordained and installed. The brass processional cross was restored.
1997 CLLC became a member of the Lutheran Foundation (created with funds from the sale of Lutheran Hospital in Ft Wayne) entitling the church to annual partnership grants of $10,000 and the opportunity to apply for other grants. Memorial funds were used to purchase the Christ Candle.
1998 The Chancel renovation project was completed at a cost of $8,500, primarily with memorial funds given by more than 30 families. Dedication service held May 31st. A decision was made to put a new roof on the church at a cost of nearly $10,000. Teenagers attended the national youth gathering in
1999 The first annual Valentine’s “Honey Ham for Your Honey” dinner sponsored by the Alpha group was held. Pew cushions were installed and a new piano purchased. On Sept 18-19, 52 members participated in a strategic planning process entitled “Faithful Christians-Faithful Congregation” to cast a vision for the future of CLLC. A chair lift, given in memory of Gloria Eichler, was installed.
2000 In April the congregation voted 62 to 33 to purchase the 41.5 acres across from the church bordering on Outer Drive and 850 E for $164,000. In August five acres were sold to the Clear Lake Conservancy with an option for them to purchase six more which they later executed. Again controversy developed over the direction of the church and Pastor Redmann accepted a call from the
2001 Pastor Mark Gaertner was installed on Sept 9th two days before the 9/11 terrorist attack.
2002 The question, “What can be done to replace this old basement carpet?” led to the formation of a Site Development Committee. A survey was taken to determine the needs for change and expansion.

2003 On April 27th, at the suggestion of the Site Committee, the voter’s decided to modernize the kitchen and member, Matt Fredericks, was hired to do the work and it was dedicated on Oct 5th. That was just the beginning of the changes. The vision that guided the process, “Growing as a Place of Welcome and Grace,” led to plans to make the church accessible to all ages with an inviting portico, an enlarged and welcoming narthex, a renovated fellowship hall, an elevator, ground level entryways, handicapped accessible restrooms, pastor and secretary offices and increased space for storage and education. On October 26th the voters viewed schematic drawings for a 4,200 sq ft expansion (this included a 600 sq ft portico), authorized architect Tom Meyers to complete construction documents, chose to apply for a matching grant of $208,850 from the Lutheran Foundation (granted and presented at the ground breaking in 2004), and decided to apply for the assistance of the Laborers for Christ.
GROUNDBREAKING FOR 2004-2005 EXPANSION
ARCHITECTS OF THE EXPANSION
HARRY PATTERSON LABORERS FOR CHRIST PROJECT MANAGER
AND BOB BRUICK CONGREGATIONAL LIAISON
2004 On January 25th the voter’s celebrated the completion of the land purchase with the ‘burning of the mortgage.’ Then they authorized the addition of a basement on the west side to the planned addition. Sub contractors for the expansion were chosen and on March 21st a groundbreaking ceremony was held. On May 1st the laborers for Christ began arriving in their RVs to encamp across the road. Because of the construction schedule,
2005 Although the building project grew beyond original projections to a 7091 square feet (5,338 sq ft of new construction and 1753 sq ft of remodeling), generous grants, pledges and gifts were received which will enable the $500,000 project to be completely paid for without incurring long term debt. A “Celebration of Completion” service in thanksgiving to God for the beautiful facility was held on July 17th. A new advent wreath given in memory of Mary Kate Beuchel, Bill Geary and Alice Retcher was dedicated.
JULY 17, 2005 COMPLETION CELEBRATION
2006 Because the building project was paid for with “new money” the parsonage/building fund CD (see 1991 note) was reinvested with LCEF. 4 feet of the east edge of lot 60 was sold to a neighbor who had inadvertently built the edge of his garage on the church’s property. The 35th anniversary of the ordination of Pastor Mark Gaertner was celebrated with a special service on July 9th with the pastor’s son, Evan Gaertner preaching. A pictorial directory of the
2007 CLLC began supporting foreign missionaries directly through the Together In Mission program. After our first missionary, Nathan Scheele decided to return to the states, support was shifted to Rev James May in
2008 Because of continued generous giving the number of special ministries of compassion we support was expanded to twenty four. In a special voter’s meeting the congregation voted to upgrade the older parts of the facility with new siding, new entrance doors, air conditioning for the Sunday School area and storm windows to protect our beautiful stained glass. The work was done by Home Lumber for a cost of $23,772. On July
2009 On August 16 Clear Lake Lutheran hosted the ‘first ever’
2010
Clear Lake Lutheran Church is a remarkable church. The generous outpouring of support from many members and friends will enable the church to continue to grow as a place of welcome and grace. The congregation has weathered storms, enjoyed the sunshine of happy days, and under the guidance and blessing of God looks forward to the future, trusting in His mercy and grace.
This history is a work in process and has been compiled by Pastor Gaertner from previous endeavors and primary sources. If you have corrections, additions or suggestions for changing the material please let him know. Interesting stories and tidbits are welcome. Perhaps by the 75th anniversary of the beginning of the association (2012), or the building of the church (2013), or the 50th anniversary as a “fully established church” of the LCMS (2018/9) a full narrative history can be written.
Pastors (and wives) serving at Clear Lake
1938 -1950 William Gustave (Iona) Polack
1950 -1977 Armin (Evelyn) Oldsen [from 1950 to 1956 Henry Kumnick served in the winter. Oscar Walle served as winter pastor in 1957]
1977 - 1983 Loren J (Virginia) Shiley
1983 - 1984 Melvin (Carole) Zilz [interim pastor]
1984 - 1990 Herman (Ruth) Reese
1990 - 1996 Gilbert (Bev) Meseke [permanent part time]
1996 - 2000 Kenneth (Linda) Redmann [vicared at CLLC in 1995]
2000 - 2001 Don (Barb)Rauhut [vacancy pastor]
2001 - 2010 Mark (Susan) Gaertner
In 1992 Rev Gil Meseke was instrumental in making CLLC a host congregation for fieldworkers from Concordia Theological Seminary of Ft Wayne. He also brought CTS student Martin Schroeder on as a summer vicar and youth worker for the summers of 1993 and 1994. According to Helena Ludeman he bunked in the church office. The last quarter he served he was married to Anne Lockwood, an Aussie whose father was a CTS professor.
CLLC Fieldworkers
1992 - 94 Timothy Parker
1995- 96 Mike and Marty Morehouse
Dan and Amy McQuality
1996-97 David and Mary Sell
1997-98 Paul Beisel
1998 -00 Les and Laverne Judge
1999 Dan Guagenti
2000 Jared and Jan Melius
2001/3 Don and Jennifer Peterson
2003/5 Kelly and Rebecca Reagan
2003/6 John and Debbie Turner
2005/7 J(eff) Brown
2006/8 Mark and Darlene Smith
2007/9 Nathan Ragazinskas
2008/10 Norm and Bonnie Wacker
2009-2011 Sean and Anna Willman
2010-2012 Walter Gilkey
2011 - Paul Rockrohr
CLEAR LAKE CHAPEL
There’s a little white chapel on top of a hill,
Far, far from earth’s turmoil and strife,
Where I find in its worship so solemn and still
All the things I need most in my life.
To the strains of its organ, I join in the songs
That long gladdened the hearts of God’s own,
And I’m sure that the echoes are heard by the throngs
That surround the Great Lamb on His throne.
There in God’s sacred Word the green pastures I find
Where the saints of all ages have trod;
And when its sweet message brings peace to my mind
Then I feel myself closer to God.
When over Clear Lake sounds the call of its bell,
Bidding worshippers into the fold,
Then I haste to the chapel on top of a hill
To hear the dear Gospel of old.
God bless the white chapel on top of a hill,
Far, far from earth’s turmoil and strife,
And grant all who worship there solemn and still
All the gladness of endless life!
-By Prof. W.G. Polack, LITT. D